Google Reader – a Bloglines user’s perspective

In: Blogging|Neat Stuff

24 Oct 2006

With the recent update of Google Reader, Google’s shot at an online feed reader, I just had to try it out even though I was rather contented with Bloglines. I’ve been a long-time Bloglines user (since end 2003 I think), and even though there was little in terms of innovation and useful new features happening, Bloglines was, in my opinion, ahead of its time way back in end 2003, and it provided an unchanging interface that worked (well, my opinion on that changed after using Google Reader, as we will soon find out).

Google Reader interface


So, I took some time to clear the backlog of unread articles in my 289 feed subscriptions at Bloglines recently so I can “start over” at Google Reader and not have to read the same unread articles twice. Export Bloglines to OPML, import into Google Reader… It went painlessly and I noticed that Bloglines “folders” got converted into “Tags” in Google Reader – mmm, taaaags. But oh wait, what’s this when I try to “manage my subscriptions” – tags, folders and labels. I’m getting confused.

Google Reader - tags, folders and labels


Just to make sure that they really are the same thing, I created some test tags/labels/folders, and yes they are actually the same thing (meaning if you add a new folder, it becomes available as a label and tag). I’m sure the terms used will be made consistent as Google Reader moves out of beta (or rather, gets further along as a beta).

If you noticed how unorganized my Bloglines subscriptions are, that’s because organizing feeds was a pain on Bloglines back in the day (it was clumsy to organize feeds into folders, you had to select a feed, scroll to the dropdown, and select the action to move it into a folder), but that’s not really a problem now with the new drag and drop interface for managing subscriptions that Bloglines pushed out recently (I think). Thankfully, Google Reader makes managing subscriptions easy as well with the familiar Gmail-like labeling.

Anyhoo, I started using Google Reader for a bit to read new articles in my feeds, and it wasn’t long before I just found my killer feature: ‘mark items as read when you scroll past them’.

Google Reader's 'mark items as read when you scroll past them' preference


This preference will tell Google Reader to only mark those items you have scrolled across as read. I hated it in Bloglines where clicking on a feed would mark all its articles as read, especially for those prolific blogs or those for which I have a backlog (200 entries is usually a little too much for one sitting for good blogs). I have to say it again, this is the killer functionality for me. I’ve been bitten by interruptions and crashed browsers once too many times. I always click on feeds (in Bloglines) with more than 50 unread articles with no small amount of trepidation, fearing that I won’t be able to read them all or that I’d do something to crash Firefox (which is surprisingly common when you’re working with large datasets in JavaScript). This often results in my reluctance to click on feeds with more than 50 unread posts, and with the vicious cycle 50 becomes 200 (the Bloglines limit for unread posts) and the feed rarely gets read (happens with blogs like Scoble or news websites like The Register).

With this feature in Google Reader, I can click on “All items” even if it says there are 1 gazillion unread posts and still feel safe about not losing my place. Those of you using non-web feed reader applications may scoff at this (I’m really not sure, I haven’t used one in a long time so I only assume something like this is common in applications like NetNewsWire or FeedDemon), but I’ve yet to see this done in a web application. Offline feed readers are not really an option for me unless they integrate to an online (i.e central) source (let me know if one exists!). For this feature alone, I decided to make a switch to Google Reader from Bloglines.

Google Reader can get a little slow though, but then I only have 512MB of RAM right now so it probably isn’t indicative of anything (the new Bloglines is slow on the Macbook Pro as well I noticed). Hopefully all this will be moot when I get the 2GB RAM upgrade that’s waiting at the store. Other than that, Google Reader seems faster to respond network-wise (which I’m not surprised at, considering that it’s Google (and their distribution channels)), and it’s also prettier. Yeah, looking good matters to some people, like me (not that Google Reader is fantastic aesthetically, but it’s far less staid than Bloglines).

Now all that’s left is to keep those fingers crossed for some sexy Gmail integration – I’m thinking something like RssFwd, a wonderfully useful creation by Choon Keat. I use RssFwd to track some important blogs and to track the latest releases of TV show torrents (Choon Keat is not gonna be happy about that though heh).

10 Responses to Google Reader – a Bloglines user’s perspective

Avatar

Ragu Sivanmalai

October 25th, 2006 at 8am

While reading this article I want to invite users for a discussion in my blog

Can google get Gods mind?

This was one argument in 2004.I want to validate this argument with diverse opionions by comparing the current trends of google like the one which is described in the post above

http://ragusivanmalai.blogspot.com/2006/10/can-google-get-gods-mind.html

Come on Google users

Avatar

Kevin Yank

October 26th, 2006 at 11am

Offline feed readers are not really an option for me unless they integrate to an online (i.e central) source (let me know if one exists!).

Take a look at BlogBridge, an open source, cross-platform, desktop feed reader that synchronizes your subscriptions and article read/unread states with a free online service.

Avatar

Dan

October 3rd, 2006 at 6pm

I’m sorry, but google reader is no way near touching bloglines yet. feed editing, labeling, naming, ordering, exporting/importing, removing, subscribing is much much more easier and user friendly in bloglines, by far. google doesn;t even support ‘foreign’ alpahbets, spaces or ‘&, £’ etc in feed names. Feed management is a mess compared to blogines, but like gmail, many are blinded by the ajaxy google goodness that they seem to miss these major points. google reader is slow to load compared to bloglines, and frustratingly, hangs mid-load, even on broardband for many i’ve seen to. bloglines loads each feed, no fus, and presents it uniformly with nice spacing and no space wasted. google thinks its find to fill half a post’s space with rounded corners, shadows and such like – not good. yes, its an improvement, but not nearly as much in the feature / usability as we were expecting, let alone compared to bloglines. google do one thing well: search. gmail is great, but by no means flawless. google reader is the same.

Avatar

choonkeat

October 4th, 2006 at 6pm

oh, no worries… i throttle torrent feeds. hmm, people aren’t gonna be happy with that

btw, neat design!

Avatar

soxiam

October 26th, 2006 at 6pm

Hmmm… That’s funny. That default “mark as read” behavior was pretty much the only reason why I did NOT switch to google reader yet as I much prefer the way bloglines handle it. To each’s own I guess.

Avatar

redemption in a blog - Google Reader, so pretty…

April 29th, 2007 at 8pm

[...] a talented designer can do with user style sheets. Posted by Chu Yeow at April 29, 2007 SGT | Permalink | | Category:Mozilla [...]

Avatar

I Led You Astray « Blog responsibly.

August 15th, 2007 at 10pm

[...] This guy agrees, [...]

Avatar

rachel

August 15th, 2007 at 11pm

I agree with you about google reader. Mark As Read and scrolling by was much more intuitive and convenient for me! It took a few days to get used to it, but I love it now.

Avatar

Don't trust web apps (or how Google Reader and my ISP conspired to lose all my feeds) - redemption in a blog

August 17th, 2007 at 6pm

[...] looking for a reliable decentralized feed reader once again (having used Bloglines and of course, Google Reader prior to the catastrophe). Posted by Chu Yeow at August 17, 2007 SGT | Permalink | | Category: [...]

Avatar

Jason Things (Beta) » Blog Archive » I Led You Astray

December 12th, 2008 at 10am

[...] This guy agrees, [...]